The Cost of Holding It Together, Part 2: When Exhaustion Turns Into Self-Judgment

Part 2 of a four-part series: The Cost of Holding It Together—Burnout, Emotions, and the Body

You finally sit down after a demanding day. There are things you finished, people you showed up for, and problems you helped solve. Yet your attention settles on the email you haven’t answered, the task you postponed, or the conversation you wish you had handled differently.

You feel tired. Then comes another thought:

I should be able to handle this.

In Part 1, we explored the cost of continuing to show up while feeling depleted. This second installment considers what happens when we judge ourselves for that exhaustion—when needing rest becomes evidence, in our own minds, that we are falling short.

As a psychotherapist who often works with professionals, I’m interested in the expectations people carry alongside their responsibilities. My doctoral coursework has encouraged me to explore how emotions such as shame and guilt fit into our understanding of occupational stress and burnout.

For someone who values being capable and dependable, the question “How am I doing?” may quickly become “Am I doing enough?” Those questions can lead us toward very different answers.

You might recognize this in everyday moments: declining a request and spending the evening second-guessing yourself; taking time off while mentally rehearsing everything you need to accomplish when you return; feeling less patient at work and wondering what that says about the kind of professional you have become.

There is the experience itself, and then there is the meaning you give it.

“I have less energy today” can become “I’m lazy.”

“I need help with this workload” can become “I’m not competent.”

“I don’t have room for another commitment” can become “I’m letting everyone down.”

These interpretations deserve our curiosity. What are we expecting of ourselves, and what happens when our capacity cannot meet those expectations?

Researchers commonly distinguish guilt from shame by where the judgment is directed. Guilt tends to concern a specific behavior: I did something I regret. Shame tends to involve a broader judgment of the self: There is something wrong with me. Guilt can motivate repair, while shame is more often associated with hiding or withdrawing. In everyday life, the two can overlap.

That distinction matters when we reflect on work. If you spoke impatiently to a colleague, recognizing that may help you apologize and respond differently next time. Deciding that the interaction proves you are a terrible colleague leaves much less room for a useful response.

The relationship between guilt and burnout also appears in research. A 2021 study of teachers in Spain and Portugal found that guilt about negative attitudes toward people at work statistically helped explain the relationship between one dimension of burnout and reported psychosomatic symptoms. Because the study used data collected at one point in time, it could not establish that guilt caused those symptoms. It also examined guilt about workplace interactions specifically—not guilt about resting.

Still, the research invites a meaningful question: How do we respond to ourselves when prolonged strain affects the way we show up?

Perhaps you try to compensate by becoming more available. You accept another responsibility, answer messages later, or promise yourself you will rest once you have caught up. Consider whether those choices address what you need, or whether they temporarily quiet the discomfort of feeling that you have disappointed someone.

Your circumstances belong in this reflection, too. Financial pressure, staffing shortages, caregiving responsibilities, and workplace expectations can limit your choices. Understanding your inner dialogue should leave room for those realities. You cannot personally resolve every demand through a change in perspective.

A place to begin is to separate what happened from what you concluded about yourself.

For example: I postponed a task because I had more work than I could complete today. That description gives you something concrete to consider. Does the deadline need to change? Is there a priority to clarify? Is support available?

You might also ask:

  • What do I believe needing rest says about me?

  • Is there something specific I want to repair, or am I judging my entire worth?

  • What would be a fair expectation given my actual circumstances?

You do not have to turn these questions into another assignment. Choose one that feels relevant and give yourself a little room to answer honestly.

Caring about your work and acknowledging your limits can exist together. You can take responsibility for a difficult interaction while recognizing the strain you were under. You can value being dependable while making commitments that leave space for your own needs.

Your exhaustion deserves attention before it becomes another reason to criticize yourself.

In Part 3, we’ll explore “What Your Heartbeat Can Tell You About Stress”—an introduction to heart rate variability, its relationship to emotional regulation, and why physiological measurements need context.

Next
Next

The Cost of Holding It Together, Part 1: What Does It Take to Keep Showing Up?